Save Up To 51%
Legends of the West Error Sheet
One wrong portrait made this 1994 Legends of the West sheet a modern US stamp rarity. It mistakenly pictured Bill Pickett's brother Ben instead of the famous cowboy. Recalled after the error was discovered, just 150,000 sheets were sold through a lottery.
Discover King Tut's Tomb
On November 4, 1922, one of the greatest archaeological discoveries in history began with a single step buried beneath the sands of Egypt’s Valley of the Kings. A century later, Great Britain issued stamps celebrating the unearthing of Pharaoh Tutankhamun's tomb.
Give the Gift of Stamps!
As the holiday season approaches, finding the perfect gift for the stamp collector in your life is easy! A Mystic Stamp Gift Card lets them choose the stamps they’ve been wishing for. Give them a gift they’ll love!
New Arrivals – Rare Finds!
Some stamps don't come our way very often! We've recently added a selection of hard-to-find stamps that collectors won't want to miss. Take a look at these new arrivals while they're available!
2026 New Issue Stamps
Keep your collection up to date with the latest stamps from the US Postal Service.
The Persian Rug: One of America’s Most Striking Stamps
Engraved in three colors to stop counterfeiters
In 1871 the government paid for a stamp that looked more like currency than a tax stamp. The $200 Small Persian Rug was made to prove payment of tax on large property transfers, and its tricolor engraving, special inks, and embedded threads were meant to stop counterfeiters and stamp reuse. Only about 121 survive, and Mystic has just one.
Featured Products
Save Up To 34%
Save Up To 27%
Save Up To 39%
Save Up To 11%
Explore Former Soviet Union States with This Collection
The Soviet Union formed in 1922 and dissolved in December 1991, and today its 15 republics are all independent nations. This collection brings together mint and used stamps from every one of them, from Armenia to Uzbekistan. Spaceflight, historic landmarks, and national symbols tell the story, along with a Ukrainian stamp issued during its war with Russia."
Stay Social
Most Orders Ship
within 1 Business Day
90 Day Return Policy
Satisfaction Guaranteed
Earn Reward Points
for FREE Stamps & More